top of page

Senator Escudero cautions senator-judges against intimidating impeachment witnesses

Senate Impeachment Court Presiding Officer Francis "Chiz" Escudero on Thursday urged fellow senator-judges and legal counsels to temper their questioning.

Paraluman News

​

​

November 12, 2026

A screen grab of a photo of Senator Francis Escudero from the Facebook page of the Senate of the Philippines.

Senate Social Media Unit

Senate Impeachment Court Presiding Officer Francis "Chiz" Escudero on Thursday urged fellow senator-judges and legal counsels to temper their questioning during Vice President Sara Duterte’s impeachment trial, warning that frustrating or evasive answers from witnesses do not automatically warrant contempt citations.


Opening the day’s proceedings, Escudero underscored that taking an oath to tell the truth does not strip witnesses of their constitutional and procedural protections.


"An answer which may be unsatisfactory is not inherently contemptible," Escudero told the chamber, pointing to Supreme Court jurisprudence that discourages courts from wielding their contempt powers excessively.


He cited Section 3, Rule 132 of the Rules on Evidence, which shields witnesses from insulting, irrelevant, or improper questions, as well as harsh treatment. The rule also guards against forcing witnesses to give answers that could lead to criminal liability or needless reputational harm, barring specific legal exceptions.


While acknowledging that a string of "I do not know" or "I do not recall" responses can test the chamber's patience, Escudero stressed that senator-judges should simply weigh those answers based on their actual evidentiary merit rather than resorting to threats.


"We must refrain from resorting to a manner of questioning or to making declarations that elicit fear rather than candor," he said, adding that his reminder applied equally to himself after admitting his own patience had worn thin in earlier hearings.


Escudero also drew a clear line between standard Senate legislative inquiries and an impeachment trial, reminding his colleagues that sitting as judges demands stricter impartiality, restraint, and courtroom decorum.


His manifestation came on the heels of tense exchanges in prior sessions, where several senator-judges grilled defense witnesses over their credibility and floated the idea of citing them for contempt. Escudero maintained that the court must carefully separate testimony that merely displeases a questioner from actual contumacious behavior.


Following the manifestation, Senator-Judge Panfilo Lacson moved to have Escudero’s reminder formally distributed to all members of the court, noting that a quorum had not yet been established at the time of the address.


"I may respectfully suggest that we send in writing the memo or whatever you call it that you just read. So, everybody will be notified," Lacson said.


Escudero accepted the recommendation, confirming that copies of his statement would be circulated to all senator-judges and entered into the official trial record. Paraluman News from a report of Wilnard Bacelonia/Philippine News Agency

LATEST NEWS

POLITICS

bottom of page