top of page

Prosecution questions VP Duterte, husband's lifestyle in impeachment trial

House prosecutors on Thursday, Nov. 12, questioned whether Vice President Sara Duterte and her husband, lawyer Manases Carpio, had complied with constitutional and legal requirements for public officials and their families to live modestly, citing a P205,000 dinner in Japan and a P256,000 shoe giveaway in Malaysia.

Paraluman News

​

​

November 12, 2026

The Senate impeachment court opens the 43rd day of Vice President Sara Duterte's trial on Nov. 12, 2026. House prosecutors questioned whether Duterte and her husband, lawyer Manases Carpio, were living in accordance with the constitutional requirement of modest living.

Facebook / Senate of the Philippines

House prosecutors on Thursday, Nov. 12, questioned whether Vice President Sara Duterte and her husband, lawyer Manases Carpio, had complied with constitutional and legal requirements for public officials and their families to live modestly, citing a P205,000 dinner in Japan and a P256,000 shoe giveaway in Malaysia.


During the cross-examination of defense witnesses, House private prosecutor Virgil Ligutan argued that the couple's spending habits were relevant to the impeachment proceedings and should be examined against standards requiring public officials and their families to avoid extravagant displays of wealth.


According to a Philippine News Agency (PNA) report, Ligutan raised the issue while questioning defense witness Anel Martin Antero, who testified that Carpio used his credit card to pay for a dinner attended by eleven friends in Tokyo on May 19, 2023.


"An official and their family should lead a modest life. This goes into the heart of the controversy. So how is that not relevant?" Ligutan told the Senate impeachment court.


He also questioned whether spending about P200,000 on a single meal was consistent with the obligation of public officials and their families to live simply.


"Kaya po ba ng ating mga kababayan na kumain sa isang upuan, gagastos ng PHP200,000? Is that leading a modest life?" he asked.


Ligutan maintained that Carpio's status as a private citizen did not exempt him from standards that apply to the families of public officials.


"An official and their families, including a legally married spouse, they are bound by the requirements of the law to lead a modest life," he said.


Paraluman News from a report of Philippine News Agency

The defense, however, argued that Carpio was not the respondent in the impeachment case and that Antero's testimony was limited to explaining the credit card transaction.


PNA reported that Antero later acknowledged he had no photograph proving that 11 people attended the dinner and no document showing that Carpio was reimbursed for the expense.


In a separate line of questioning, House private prosecutor Reynaldo Robles cited a P256,000 shoe purchase made during a basketball team's trip to Malaysia after defense witness Chadrin Parian confirmed that Carpio bought shoes for both players and adults in the group.


"Ito po bang ganitong paggastos ng PHP256,000 para manlibre ng sapatos, eh ito po ba halimbawa ng isang kapamilya ng public official na namumuhay nang simple at payak?" Robles asked.


He later referenced legal provisions requiring public officials and their families to avoid ostentatious displays of wealth.


"They should live simple lives. They should avoid ostentatious display of wealth in any form," Robles said.


After the defense objected, Senate impeachment court Presiding Officer Francis "Chiz" Escudero allowed the questioning to proceed.


Parian said he could not judge Carpio's lifestyle, replying: "Hindi ko po alam. I cannot answer for him po."


However, he admitted he could not afford to spend P256,000 on shoes for others.


"May nabigyan din po ako ng mga sapatos. Pero 'yung ganito na ganyang kadami, PHP256,000, hindi ko po kaya 'yan," he said.


The transactions were among those previously flagged by forensic accounting expert Alexander Cabrera, who testified on alleged unexplained wealth and undeclared assets involving Duterte and Carpio, according to PNA.

LATEST NEWS

POLITICS

bottom of page