top of page

'Morally acceptable' for US troops to disobey questionable orders, says Catholic archbishop

Archbishop Timothy Broglio says it is "morally acceptable" for U.S. troops to disobey orders that conflict with their conscience, expressing concern over potentially unlawful or morally questionable directives. His remarks come amid President Trump's controversial statements on domestic military deployment and Greenland.

Jasper Ward/Reuters

January 21, 2026

'Morally acceptable' for US troops to disobey questionable orders, says Catholic archbishop

Soldiers assigned to the U.S. Army Reserve’s 1st Mission Support Command carry their rifles to a shooting range ahead of a live-fire training exercise at Camp Santiago in Salinas, Puerto Rico, January 10, 2026.

Ricardo Arduengo/Reuters

The Catholic archbishop overseeing the church's work with members of the U.S. military said it would be "morally acceptable" for troops to disobey orders that went against their consciences.


Archbishop Timothy Broglio said he was worried some members of the military could be put into situations where they are ordered to do something considered "morally questionable."


Broglio, who also heads the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops, told BBC News on Sunday that "it would be morally acceptable to disobey that order but that's perhaps putting that individual in an untenable situation and that's my concern."


Broglio did not indicate what he considered a morally questionable order.


His comments come as President Donald Trump has sought to deploy troops onto the streets of U.S. cities and threatens possible military action to take control of Greenland.


The Pentagon did not immediately respond to a request for comment.


Earlier this month, Trump told The New York Times he is constrained only by his "own morality."


The archbishop expressed concern over Trump's comments, suggesting that international law and one's own moral principles should go hand in hand.


He said it does not seem reasonable for the U.S. to attack and occupy Greenland, which is governed by Denmark, a NATO ally.


"It'd be one thing if the people of Greenland wanted to, wanted to be annexed, that would be one situation," Broglio said. "But taking it by force when we already have treaties there that allow for a military installation in Greenland? It doesn't seem necessary."


Broglio is the latest leader of the Catholic Church to raise concerns about Trump's demands. On Monday, three fellow archbishops decried the direction of U.S. foreign policy. Church leaders have also pushed back on the Trump administration's immigration agenda.


Six Democratic members of the U.S. Congress in a video last year reminded members of the military that it was their duty to reject unlawful orders, drawing reproach from the Trump administration, including a Pentagon decision to demote Senator Mark Kelly of Arizona from his rank of retired Navy captain.

-Jasper Ward/Reuters

TOP POLITICAL STORIES

Trump says Iran faces economic collapse or tougher US action

Trump says Iran faces economic collapse or tougher US action

PH Senate ratifies visiting forces agreements with Canada, New Zealand

PH Senate ratifies visiting forces agreements with Canada, New Zealand

North Korea: South Korea's nuclear submarine plans threaten regional security

North Korea: South Korea's nuclear submarine plans threaten regional security

LATEST NEWS

Heavy rain hits Beijing as Typhoon Dolphin sweeps across China

Heavy rain hits Beijing as Typhoon Dolphin sweeps across China

One dead, 172 rescued after ferry from Bali catches fire

One dead, 172 rescued after ferry from Bali catches fire

153 civilians killed in 2025 US military ops, says official citing Pentagon report

153 civilians killed in 2025 US military ops, says official citing Pentagon report

bottom of page